DTF vs HTV: Which One is Better?

Attracted by shirts with creative prints and feeling about designing one on your own? DTF and HTV (heat transfer vinyl) are two popular ways available for apparel printing.

If you are a newbie, struggling between the two is quite normal. This article will take you through the meanings of DTF and HTV, show you how to do DTF transfers and heat transfer vinyl, and present to you the differences between DTF and HTV printing. Finally, advice on the best printer will be offered. Take a look now！

What to Know About DTF

What is DTF Printing

Direct-to-film printing (DTF) involves the direct transfer of a design by first printing it on a special film and then using a heat press to transfer the design to a garment. This printing method is used on textiles, including apparel such as T-shirts, jeans, jackets, hoodies, sportswear, and accessories like bags and belts.

How to make DTF transfers

• Create a digital design via graphic design software.
• Use a specialized DTF printer, loaded with textile-grade pigment inks, to get the design printed on a PET film.
• Dry the film, as the printed film is coated with a special adhesive powder that allows the ink to bond with the fabric.
• Heat-press the film onto the fabric.
• Peel off the transfer film, and then you'll find the design ready.

For DTF newbies, an intelligent and handy printing machine is preferred. xTool Apparel Printer stands as your best DTF solution.  Powered by the latest dual print head technology and the AI camera, Apparel Printer makes DTF printing an easy work for almost everyone.

The imported design will be printed on the PET film, which is then powdered evenly and smoothly sent to the curing oven for baking without any manual operation. With only one click, the whole process is done automatically and coherently. After you upload all the design files at once, the printer can handle all the tasks for you.

Pros of DTF Printing

• Works well on a range of materials, including cotton, denim, nylon, polyester, blends, leather, and more.
• Works best for complex and full-color design and photos.
• Cost-effective for small batch printing.
• Durable and can withstand multiple washes.

 Cons of DTF Printing

• Higher setup and running costs.
• More experience is demanded.
• Textured prints can make the fabric stiff.

What to Know About HTV

What is HTV

Heat transfer vinyl (HTV) is a speciality polyurethane with a heat-activated adhesive (typically polyester-based) that can be used on certain fabrics and materials to apply designs to promotional products, textiles and apparel. It can be cut, weeded, and placed on a substrate for application via a heat press. Vinyl cutters, weeding tools and a heat press or iron are used to transfer vinyl onto the product.

Normally, the HTV design is created using single-color vinyl sheets, thus best suiting text-based designs, logos, and simple patterns with limited colors. However, printable HTV can expand color choices. Any desirable design can be printed on special printable vinyl sheets.

Vinyl sheets vary in colors, textures, and gradients. It’s one of those versatile methods that offer easy entry for newcomers, attracting a large group of DIY lovers and businesses.

How to Do Heat Transfer Vinyl

• Create a digital design pattern.
• Load the vinyl sheet into a vinyl cutter, such as  M1 Ultra, and cut the vinyl. For printable vinyl, just color-print the design of your choice onto the vinyl sheet.
• Use a weeding tool to remove the excess vinyl from around and inside the design.
• Place the cut vinyl design onto the top of the fabric.
• Use a heat press or your household iron to apply heat. Time and pressure settings for HTV should be based on the type of fabric and vinyl.

Pros of HTV

• Ease of use and beginner-friendly.
• Quick turnaround.
• Works on both natural fabrics and synthetic fabrics.
• Highly versatile with a range of vinyl types (e.g., glitter, color-changing, puff) for different effects.

Cons of HTV

• Unsuitable for highly complicated designs.
• Bulk production can be time-consuming.
• May peel, crack, or fade over time.

DTF vs HTV: What's the Difference

Materials Compatibility

Both techniques are highly versatile with regard to material compatibility.

DTF can be applied to a wide range of fabrics, including cotton, cotton blends, polyester, rayon and silk. Moreover, DTF printing is not limited to textiles, it can also be used on ceramics and metallic surfaces, offering endless possibilities for customization.

HTV prints are also compatible with a large variety of materials. For the fabric category, HTV printing works best on cotton and polyester; and in terms of the non-fabric materials, wood and ceramics stand at the most common choices.

Design Complexity

DTF performs well in replicating complex designs, including gradients, fine details, and photorealistic images. It can reproduce intricate artwork with high color accuracy and fine lines. 

With regard to normal HTV, the design is usually cut from vinyl sheets, which limits the range of colors and intricacy. For printable vinyl, more complicated designs are allowed. And you can directly transfer the design onto the fabric without taking extra time to put each sheet layer on top of each other. 

Durability

DTF printing can guarantee good durability as long as the heat press process is done carefully. It can withstand repeated washing and shows little sign of wear. 

HTV prints are durable, but also more prone to scratching and cracking over time, especially with heavy use. Color Choices

Color Choices

Color choices for DTF printing are unlimited. DTF prints use water-based and solvent-based inks available in CMYK colors, which allows for a wide range of color combinations.

xTool Apparel Printer is compatible with xTool Selected Apparel Printer Ink (CMYKW) , a kind of pigment-based ink allowing for full-range colors. If you want higher color accuracy with certification, then the xTool Selected Apparel Printer Ink (CMYKW) is worth trying.

HTV design can also be multi-colored. For plain heat transfer vinyl, it is limited to the vinyl colors you have, as designs are cut from single-color vinyl sheets. But the printable HTV has no color limits, and you can create full-color designs as you like.

Costs

DTF printing requires huge initial investment in equipment, thus being more expensive for starters. However, for large businesses or experienced crafters, DTF printers could bring along better batch printing experience. HTV printing, in contrast, costs relatively less. It comes off as a more ideal choice for DIYers or budding crafters.

Production Speed

Due to the extra steps of weeding and putting multiple layers of vinyl sheets on the top of the fabric, HTV printing has a slower production speed compared to DTF printing. But for single-color and simple designs, HTV printing could be more efficient over short runs.

Production Quantity

DTF printing technique performs better when the production quantity increases. You can combine steps in the DTF printing process, including bulk printing and storing the transfers until they are in need. 

However, HTV will take more time and come off less efficient in terms of large production quantity. It is ideal for one-off designs or small batches because it requires minimal setup, and you can work with individual vinyl sheets for each design without much waste.

DTF vs HTV: Which One to Choose

Since all the differences have been listed out, now you can move on to decide which one is more suitable for you based on their advantages and disadvantages.

You can choose DTF when:

• You want to create a complex design with intricate details or a high-resolution, photorealistic print.
• You need durable prints for frequently washed items.
• The production quantity is large.
• You have the customization demand for a wider range of materials.

You can choose HTV when:

• You are on a budget, or you are a beginner.
• You prefer more manual work for DIY enjoyment.
• The design you want to create is simple.

FAQs: DTF vs HTV

Which is better, DTF or HTV?

Both techniques are good printing options. Which one to choose is up to your needs. If you prefer complex designs and large production volume, DTF printing is recommended. If you are unfamiliar with the printing technique, and simply want to try some easy designs in a cost-effective manner, then HTV is more ideal.

Does DTF last longer than HTV?

Yes. In fact, both DTF and HTV prints are durable for ordinary use. However, if you want to put the printed product into heavy use, then DTF printing stands as a better option.

Is HTV cheaper than DTF?

Yes. The initial cost of DTF printing is higher, and buying all the required equipment could be a big spending. If you have a tight budget, just opt for HTV printing and get some easy fun. If you hope to build up small businesses or engage in DIY for longer time, then DTF printer comes off as a better choice.

Does DTF feel like HTV?

DTF transfers have a more fabric-like feel than traditional heat vinyl transfers. They might have a slightly plastic feel initially, especially with thicker transfer films. After washes the DTF prints tend to soften up, becoming more flexible and comfortable.

Heat transfer vinyl (HTV) can also feel slightly plastic, but some vinyl types are softer. After washing, the feel of HTV generally doesn't change much.

Conlusion

To wrap it up, the choice of printing technique depends on your demand. DTF printing serves better for those who have more budget and are eager to dive deep into the DIY crafting business. DTF prints can be more complex and delicate. HTV printing, in contrast, is more cost-effective, beginner-friendly, and ideal for whoever wants to enjoy simple fun. Now, I bet you've got an option, just go for it and get started doing handicrafts!

Related Reading:

DTF Vs Sublimation Printing: Which is Better?

DTF Vs Screen Printing: Which is Better?

DTF Vs DTG: Which is Better?

Sublimation Vs Heat Transfer Vinyl: Which is Better?