Sublimation Vs Heat Transfer Vinyl: Which One to Choose?
Exploring fabric printing techniques for your crafting project or business? Chances are, you have come across sublimation and heat transfer vinyl (HTV).
One method is simple, involving just cutting and heat pressing, but it limits design complexity. The other offers realistic, full-color prints but works best on specific fabrics.
Read this guide on sublimation vs heat transfer vinyl to uncover the technical and practical differences between the two, so that you can make the right choice for your next project.
In This Article
- Understanding Sublimation Printing
- Understanding Heat Transfer Vinyl Printing
- Sublimation Vs Heat Transfer Vinyl: What’s the Difference?
- Sublimation Vs Heat Transfer Vinyl: Which One to Choose?
- FAQs: Sublimation vs Vinyl
Understanding Sublimation Printing
Sublimation printing is a process of transferring digital images onto polyester-based fabrics and other coated substrates. It’s based on the phase-state change process ‘sublimation’ i.e. conversion of solid directly to gas. In this process, the solid dye particles vaporize and permeate into the fabric, becoming part of it.
Sublimation is best known for transferring realistic and photographic images onto light-colored polyesters. Ideally, the fabric needs to have at least 65% polyester to undergo sublimation. For other fabrics like cotton, printing is possible but with an additional coating of vinyl or a polymer.
Here’s how you can carry out sublimation printing:
- Prepare a digital image using design software.
- Print the design onto a special sublimation paper using dye sublimation ink.
- Place the printed sublimation paper over the fabric, and supply heat using a heat press. Under heat and pressure, the dye converts to gas, and bonds with the polyester fibers. The design blends inside the fabric, and the end result is a smooth colorful print.
Pros of Sublimation Printing
- Produces high-quality photo-realistic prints.
- Works best on light polyester fabrics or coated surfaces.
- The soft feel of the fabric remains preserved.
- Prints are resistant to feeding, cracking, or peeling.
Cons of Sublimation Printing
- The design doesn’t show up well on darker fabrics.
- Not ideal for cotton.
- Extensive setup.
xTool Heat Press
Multi-modal Heat Press for DTF, Sublimation & HTV Transfers
Flexible modes, portable or hands-free, meet most printing needs like T-shirts, bags, shoes, slates, coasters, and more.
Learn MoreUnderstanding Heat Transfer Vinyl Printing
Heat Transfer Vinyl (HTV) is a straightforward method for customizing various fabrics, including cotton and nylon, with vibrant, textured designs. Normally, the design is created using single-color vinyl sheets. So, the process best suits text-based designs, logos, and simple patterns with limited colors. However, printable HTV can expand color choices.
HTV sheets come in different colors, textures, and gradients, allowing you to choose a texture of your choice. It’s one of those versatile methods that offer easy entry for newcomers, which is why it’s a preferred choice for enthusiasts and small businesses.
Here’s how you can create an HTV design:
- Create a design pattern digitally. For best results, keep it simple.
- Load the vinyl sheet into a vinyl cutter, such as xTool M1 or M1 Ultra, and cut the vinyl. For printable vinyl, just color-print the design of your choice onto the plain vinyl sheet.
- Remove the excess vinyl from around and inside the design using a weeding tool.
- Place the cut vinyl design onto the top of the fabric.
- Use a heat press or your household iron to apply heat. Time and pressure vary based on texture and type of vinyl.
Pros of Heat Transfer Vinyl
- Beginner-friendly process that requires minimal equipment.
- Ideal for bold textual designs and logos.
- Works on both natural fabrics and synthetic fabrics.
- Highly versatile with a range of vinyl types (e.g., glitter, color-changing, puff) for different effects.
- Quick turnaround time for one-off designs.
Cons of Heat Transfer Vinyl
- Bulk production can be time-consuming.
- May peel, crack, or fade over time.
Sublimation Vs Heat Transfer Vinyl: What’s the Difference?
The earlier section gave you a glimpse of each method’s strengths. However, making the right choice means diving deeper into key aspects. So, let’s compare sublimation and heat transfer vinyl in terms of design complexity, color options, feel, production time, and setup cost.
| Sublimation | Heat Transfer Vinyl (HTV) | |
|---|---|---|
| Design Complexity | Full-color, photo-realistic designs | Textual Design and Logos |
| Feel & Texture | Soft, seamless finish | Noticeable texture |
| Color Options | Unlimited | Pre-made vinyl colors Unlimited (with Printable HTV) |
| Supported Fabrics | Light-colored polyester or blends (65%+). | Cotton, polyester, nylon, leather, and more |
| Durability | No Fading | Prone to Peel |
| Production Time | Faster | Slower |
| Costs | High | Low |
| Quantity | Bulk production | One-off or small batches |
Design Complexity
The nature of the design each technique can handle is different. With HTV, the design is usually cut from vinyl sheets, which limits the range of colors and intricacy. Each layer of color requires a separate vinyl sheet, making multi-color designs challenging and time-consuming.
In contrast, sublimation printing uses a digital process to transfer designs onto sublimation paper. This means you can replicate any designs that can be digitally created, from complex patterns to realistic photos.
Design Feel and Texture
In the HTV process, the vinyl sits on top of the fabric, which creates a noticeable texture. This layered design can make the fabric less breathable and slightly heavier in the printed areas.
On the other hand, in sublimation, the dye becomes part of the fabric by bonding directly with the fibers. This keeps the fabric’s original softness and texture intact. The result is a smooth, lightweight finish that feels like the fabric itself.
Color Choices
As mentioned earlier, sublimation uses digital printing, so all colors that CYMK inks can create are possible. This allows you to print detailed, and multi-color designs easily.
Vinyl sheets come in different color options and textures like color-changing, gradient, glitter, or puff vinyl. These are great for unique effects, but the design is limited to the vinyl colors you have. However, for complex design options, you need to switch to printable HTV, which lets you print any design onto vinyl.
Compatible Fabrics
Sublimation works best on light-colored synthetic fabrics, especially polyester. The dye bonds well with synthetic fibers but doesn’t have a white base. This means designs appear dull or see-through on dark fabrics. Ideally, the fabric should have at least 65% polyester. There’s a workaround for other fabrics too, but you’ll need to add a base coat of vinyl.
Vinyl works on a variety of fabrics regardless of color. It can be applied to cotton, polyester, poly-cotton blends, nylon, and even leather. Since vinyl is bold and opaque, it stays prominent both on light and dark fabric equally.
Costs Involved
Heat transfer vinyl is not only simple but also cost-effective. That’s why it’s the preferred choice for DIYers and crafters. To give you an idea of costs, here’s a breakdown:
A pack of 16 HTV vinyl sheets costs about $12.99 at xTool store. A 4-in-1 vinyl cutter, like the xTool M1 Ultra, is priced at around $999, and a basic heat press can cost as little as $53.99. In many cases, a household iron can work as a heat press substitute, further reducing costs.
On the other hand, sublimation requires more specialized tools and materials. You need a sublimation printer, sublimation paper, sublimation dyes, and a heat press, which is typically larger and more expensive than what’s used for HTV. Maintenance and ink costs are recurring too.
Durability
HTV creates a layered design that sits on top of the fabric. Yes, it is durable, but also more prone to scratching and cracking over time, especially with heavy use. On average, HTV designs can last up to 50 washes before signs of wear appear.
Whereas, sublimation embeds the design directly into the fabric, making it part of the material itself. This eliminates any possibility of cracking or peeling. Fading is also rare, as the dye bonds at a molecular level with the fabric.
Production Time
HTV is a simple method but involves more manual effort. You need to cut the design from the vinyl/s, weed out the excess material, align it on the fabric, and then use a heat press to transfer it. The span increases if you have more colors in the design. In comparison, sublimation just involves printing the whole design once and heat pressing it.
Quantity
Both HTV and sublimation can be used for creating single or multiple designs, but the cost-effectiveness varies depending on the quantity. HTV is ideal for one-off designs or small batches because it requires minimal setup, and you can work with individual vinyl sheets for each design without much waste.
In contrast, sublimation shines in bulk production or larger batches. Once the design and setup are prepared, sublimation can handle multiple items more efficiently.
Sublimation Vs Heat Transfer Vinyl: Which One to Choose?
We have thoroughly explained the differences, and the distinction between sublimation and heat transfer vinyl (HTV) is clear. Both are excellent printing methods, but the choice ultimately depends on your specific printing needs and requirements.
You can choose HTV when:
- Vibrant textual designs and logos.
- You are working with cotton, nylon, or other non-polyester fabrics.
- You need a cost-effective solution for small-scale or one-off projects.
Use sublimation when:
- You’re printing on light-colored polyester blends.
- The design is detailed and involves full-color images.
- You need seamless prints that preserve the fabric’s softness and breathability.
FAQs: Sublimation vs Vinyl
Which is better, sublimation or vinyl?
Both are excellent methods for creating designs on fabrics. The best one is subjective to the needs. For light-colored polyester fabrics, when vibrant and photographic images are needed, sublimation is ideal. For bold, textured designs like logos, text, and cartoons, HTV is the better choice.
What lasts longer sublimation or vinyl?
Sublimation, without a doubt, as the design bonds directly with the fabric and becomes part of it. In contrast, HTV designs are layered and prone to cracking.
Is printable vinyl the same as sublimation?
Printable vinyl is a digital version of HTV where you can print any type of full-colored, complex designs onto vinyl and then heat press it – the texture and feel are the same. But the process is not the same as sublimation where the inks permeate into fabric. The only similarity is they both use digital printing.
Can I use my sublimation printer for printable vinyl?
No, it’s not possible because sublimation printers use dye-based inks that are not compatible with printable vinyl. However, it is possible to heat press sublimation inks onto clear or white vinyl, which can then be applied to fabrics where direct sublimation isn’t an option. This technique is commonly used as a workaround for materials like cotton.
For more questions. Please join our community to get inspired!
